Disagreement with Sigmond Freuds The Future of an Illiusion Essay

To a sure extent I can agree with Freuds views on graphic instinct. Without manmade laws and coercion or rules that are p dislikeed by God, civilization would not stretch out or even direct been born. Yet, as is the case with many former(a) people, I disagree with his views on religion. I do not cogitate that religion was created by man, but by a higher being. It is unworkable for me to believe that science willing destroy religion because for every movement science answers many more questions arise. The more science reveals about character the more apparent it is to me that only if a higher being could have created everything. As Freud states I am one of the unpersuadable. Civilization is not only made by technological development but also by a set of rules. The rules remove mans foul instincts such(prenominal) as killing, incest, and cannibalism, which are the elements that work to destroy civilization. Without guidelines or laws our actions would be the hom ogeneous as those of wild animals. Freud says that these laws and doctrines were established so that we could unite and band against the our opponent nature. Imposing laws upon people is a necessary element, yet it causes people to resent this coercion away from their natural instincts. After being forced against their will these people begin to hate civilization but at the selfsame(prenominal) time they continue to love it because it provides them with their necessities to live. Freud c alones the people the masses because they are the bulk of civilization. He says that they are ignorant and lazy, because of this, it easy for them to lapse back to instinctual air and into the chaos of nature. Name 2Freud says civilization is founded on religion. For example, T... ...Union of Soviet state-controlled Republics is a good example of Freuds envisioned civilization. Instead relying on a higher being, the state name 4was to meet all of the peoples needs. When the country fa iled economically, there were generations of atheists with no belief body to guide them. This country collapsed because of many reasons but one of them could be the neglect of religion. After reading The Future of an Illusion I wondered why Freud was so strongly set against God. Instead of basing his beliefs on faith, he invested himself in the scientific method. Since he could not conduct experiments that led him to the answer, he concluded that it was inconceivable for a God to exist. Maybe science will one day explain the phenomenona of today, but there will always be unreciprocated questions. A discovery will only lead to more questions.